The Toronto Blue Jays are facing a critical offseason decision this offseason. One of their key players has openly advocated for the organization to prioritize the Vladimir Guerrero Jr. extension over entering the Juan Soto sweepstakes. Guerrero, who continues to be a figure in the Blue Jays lineup, is projected to receive $29 million through arbitration in the years. However, his future with the team beyond 2026 hangs uncertain, with his impending free agency.

This appeal to prioritize Guerrero Jr.’s extension reflects the growing sentiment around him being not only a valuable asset but also the centerpiece of the Blue Jays’ success. The standout hitter has established himself by coming in second in MVP voting in 2021 and receiving two All-Star nods; Guerrero Jr.’s combination of power at the plate and strong leadership qualities makes him an essential part of Toronto’s lineup. Moreover, the Blue Jays’ resurgence as a contender for the postseason is largely attributed to Vladimir’s role in the team—a sentiment backed by their 30-year-old star pitcher.

Soto or stability: ‘La Makina’ prioritizes Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s impact

Jays star José Berríos was spotted in a recent interview with Jarniel Canales of El Vocero de Puerto Rico. When asked about the team’s pursuit of Juan Soto during a recent interview, Berríos replied, “It would be incredible (to sign Soto), but first we have to sign Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who I understand is the pillar of the team,” adding, “When we sign ‘Vlady,’ we can sign whoever they want. But I think the priority should be Vladimir Guerrero Jr., and then if we add Juan Soto, it would be a perfect world.”

Soto has become a sought-after player due to his ability to get on base and his reliable power at the plate. So, acquiring him would definitely shake up the Jays’ lineup, but it would mean giving up promising young talents and financial flexibility. Moreover, this internal push to extend Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s presence reflects a broader dilemma for the Blue Jays‘ front office.

Retaining Guerrero would provide the team with stability and continuity for years to come, but taking a bold risk with Soto could potentially be a big payoff in the future. Now, general manager Ross Atkins is in a spot as he navigates an offseason that will shape Toronto’s direction for years to come—whether the Blue Jays will agree with Berríos’ take or roll the dice on acquiring Soto remains unclear as of yet.

A team built around Vladdy: Why is it important?

The Blue Jays have greatly benefited from Guerrero Jr.’s leadership, especially in 2024. With his .286 batting average, along with 32 home runs and 102 RBIs, Vladimir led the team in various offensive categories. Besides delivering 21 game-winning hits, which contributed to Toronto securing a spot in the postseason, Guerrero Jr.’s consistency in playing 158 games was crucial for a team that faced injuries during the season. Throughout a year of obstacles and setbacks, Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s consistent output solidified his position as the backbone of the team.

Outside of the field of play, Guerrero Jr.’s leadership remained prominent as he actively mentored talents such as Davis Schneider and Addison Barger to help them adjust swiftly. Also, his fluency in both English and Spanish enabled Vladimir to connect players from diverse backgrounds, including George Springer and Santiago Espinal, thus promoting a sense of unity within the team.

While the temptation of adding Juan Soto is appealing, the potential repercussions of team dynamics and parting ways with a talent like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. could be significant. Looking towards the future, the Toronto team faces one question: Should they take the chance of trading Guerrero Jr. with uncertain outcomes or prioritize securing his place in the team for long-term success?

What do you think works best for the team? Share your opinion below.